Personal Injury Structured Settlements: How They Work and When They Make Sense

Most structured settlements in the United States start exactly where yours did or will, with a personal injury case. A personal injury structured settlement resolves your claim with guaranteed future payments instead of one lump sum check. The defendant's insurer buys an annuity, a life insurance company sends the payments, and for physical injuries the money generally arrives free of federal income tax. Below we cover how these arrangements get set up, the tax rules that make them attractive, the payment designs we see most often, and what you can do if the schedule no longer fits your life.

What Is a Personal Injury Structured Settlement?

A personal injury structured settlement is an agreement that pays your injury compensation as a series of scheduled future payments rather than a single lump sum. The paying insurer funds an annuity for your benefit, and the annuity issuer makes every payment on the negotiated schedule.

The concept has been part of federal law for more than four decades. Congress passed the Periodic Payment Settlement Act in 1982, which added the tax provisions that make these arrangements work. If you want the full background on the mechanics, our guide to what a structured settlement is goes deeper on the moving parts.

What makes the personal injury version distinct is the tax treatment. Compensation for physical injury or physical sickness is excluded from gross income, and a properly designed structure extends that exclusion across every future payment. That is the reason your attorney likely brought it up before you settled.

How a Personal Injury Case Becomes a Structured Settlement

The structure is negotiated as part of your settlement, before anything is signed. Once you and the defendant agree that some or all of your compensation will be paid over time, four parties make it happen.

The qualified assignment step matters more than most people realize. Under Internal Revenue Code Section 130, the defendant's obligation moves to an assignment company affiliated with the annuity issuer. In other words, the party that hit you with a car or made the defective product is completely out of your financial life. The assignment company holds the payment obligation from then on, funded by an annuity from a regulated life insurance company, and that insurer is the one that sends your checks.

We have dealt with every major annuity issuer, including MetLife, Prudential, and New York Life. Our issuer guides cover who these companies are and how to read their financial strength ratings.

Are Personal Injury Structured Settlement Payments Taxable?

Payments for physical injury or physical sickness are generally free of federal income tax under IRC Section 104(a)(2). The exclusion covers the entire scheduled payment, including the investment growth built into the annuity, which is what separates a structure from investing a lump sum yourself.

The IRS explains this treatment in Publication 4345 (opens in a new tab). There are real limits. Punitive damages are taxable even in physical injury cases. Interest that accrues on a judgment is taxable. Compensation for purely emotional distress without physical injury is treated differently as well.

The good news is that the tax treatment was designed for exactly your situation, an injured person who needs the money to last. We break down the full rules, including what happens when payments are sold, in our guide to structured settlement federal tax rules.

Common Payment Designs in Personal Injury Cases

No two injury settlements look alike, and the payment schedule is where that shows. A structure can pay monthly for 20 years, pay for the rest of your life, hold money back for future surgeries, or step up over time as your needs grow.

The designs we see most often in personal injury cases include lifetime monthly payments with a guaranteed minimum period, level monthly payments for a fixed term, and deferred lump sums timed to future events. Severely injured claimants often combine several in one settlement. We walk through real payment schedules case type by case in our structured settlement examples guide.

Settlements for injured children add a court approval layer of their own, and the payments usually defer until adulthood. Our guide to structured settlements for minors covers how those work and who controls the money in the meantime.

If your payments depend on you being alive to receive them, you hold a life contingent structure, which has its own rules and its own market. See our life contingent structured settlement guide for that variation.

Personal Injury vs. Workers' Comp and Wrongful Death Structures

Personal injury is one of three case types that commonly produce structured settlements, and the rules differ across them. A workplace injury can produce either a workers' compensation settlement or a third party personal injury claim, and the distinction changes how a later sale is treated. Our workers' comp settlement guide draws that line in detail.

Wrongful death settlements pay surviving family members rather than the injured person, and they carry their own structuring conventions. That said, the core machinery, an annuity funded by the defendant's insurer, is the same. Our wrongful death structured settlement guide covers the differences.

Can You Sell Personal Injury Structured Settlement Payments?

Yes. Every state allows you to sell some or all of your future structured settlement payments through a court approved transfer under its Structured Settlement Protection Act. A judge reviews the deal and must find that the sale is in your best interest before it closes.

People sell for practical reasons. Medical bills are the most common one we see. After that, it is paying off high interest debt, buying a home, and covering a gap between jobs. The structure was designed around the life you had at settlement, and lives change.

We have closed more than 4,000 structured settlement transactions, many of them from personal injury cases, and we consistently beat competing offers. Get quotes from at least two or three companies before you decide anything. We encourage that comparison because we know how it usually ends. Start with our guide to selling your structured settlement or get a free quote to see what your payments are worth.

Have questions about a personal injury structure you already hold? Call us at (800) 317-3769. That gets you a direct line to our team, not a call center.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a personal injury structured settlement?

+

A personal injury structured settlement resolves an injury claim with a stream of guaranteed future payments instead of a single lump sum. The defendant's insurer funds an annuity with a life insurance company, and that company sends your payments on the schedule negotiated at settlement.

Are personal injury structured settlement payments taxable?

+

Payments for physical injury or physical sickness are generally excluded from federal income tax under IRC Section 104(a)(2), and that treatment applies to the full scheduled payments, including the growth built into them. Punitive damages and most interest are taxable. Confirm your specific situation with a tax professional.

Who actually sends my structured settlement checks?

+

In nearly every modern arrangement, a life insurance company issues the annuity and a qualified assignment company takes over the payment obligation from the defendant. The original defendant is out of the picture once the assignment closes. Your checks come from the annuity issuer, such as MetLife, Prudential, or Pacific Life.

Can I change my structured settlement payment schedule later?

+

No. The schedule is fixed when the settlement is finalized, and the issuer cannot restructure it afterward. The one exception is a court approved transfer, where you sell some or all of your future payments to a purchasing company for cash under your state's Structured Settlement Protection Act.

Can I sell only part of my personal injury structured settlement?

+

Yes. Partial sales are common and often smarter than selling everything. You can sell a set number of monthly payments or a portion of each payment, keep the rest of the stream, and every sale still goes through the same court approval process.

Why did my attorney recommend a structured settlement?

+

Attorneys recommend structures because the payments are tax free for physical injury claims, they cannot be spent all at once, and they can be timed to future needs like medical care or a child's college years. For minors and people with long term care needs, many courts expect or require a structure.